Legislation College clinic represents former Bard professor in high-stakes civil rights lawsuit

The Yale Legislation College’s Strategic Advocacy Clinic filed a harrasment criticism final week in opposition to Bard School, on behalf of the college’s recently-fired homosexual Black feminine professor.

Eda Aker

11:06 pm, Sep 14, 2022

Workers Reporter

Tim Tai, Workers Photographer

The Yale Legislation College’s Strategic Advocacy Clinic filed a lawsuit final week on behalf of a professor who alleges she confronted intercourse and race-based harassment throughout her time at Bard School.

The civil criticism was filed on Aug. 25 within the Southern District of New York. The Legislation College clinic, which focuses on prison justice and inequality points, is representing an unnamed homosexual Black feminine professor in opposition to Bard School, the plaintiff’s earlier employer. Whereas at Bard School, the plaintiff says she advocated for the victims of racial and sexual harrasment at Bard. Final 12 months, Bard School launched an investigation into the professor — finally resulting in her termination. The Legislation College clinic’s criticism was filed on prices of racial and sex-based harrassment through the plaintiff’s employment, in addition to a hostile campus setting for folks of coloration.

“Bard School purports to be a liberal, forward-thinking establishment that values range of identification and of thought,” Saja Spearman-Weaver LAW ’23 stated. “And in some methods, it could make good on its guarantees. However for our shopper, and the scholars of coloration she labored to guard, the interior politics of Bard School have been a supply of trauma and betrayal. I feel this case is exceedingly related to our nation’s continued efforts to make our conduct match our constitutional beliefs.” 

Avery Gilbert, medical lecturer and director of the strategic advocacy clinic, stated that the case includes “a protracted historical past” of the plaintiff’s detrimental experiences on account of her race, gender and sexual orientation on the “insular” and “white” campus of Bard School. 

A spokesperson for Bard School denied the validity of those claims in an announcement to the Information.

“Bard School doesn’t typically touch upon pending instances, however the allegations on this criticism are so outrageous that they require response,” the Bard School spokesperson wrote. “The criticism filed final week in opposition to Bard has no advantage, and the School will defend itself and our colleagues in opposition to these baseless claims in courtroom.”

Against this, Gilbert instructed the Information that the clinic believes the investigation into the plaintiff and her subsequent termination was “retaliatory.” The investigation had straight adopted a criticism that the professor raised to Bard School administration concerning the faculty not offering enough Title IX lodging to college students who had been sexually assaulted on campus, Gilbert stated.

Bard School, nevertheless, disputed the declare that the investigation and termination have been retaliatory.

“The plaintiff … was terminated for trigger after a radical, impartial investigation, and is making provably false statements within the criticism,” a spokesperson for Bard School wrote. “As an establishment, the School believes within the significance of details, transparency and the foundations of proof. We wish to push again on the terrifyingly profitable exploitation of falsehoods in public life.”

In keeping with Gilbert, there’s usually a “disincentive” to deliver these civil instances to the courtroom due to the facility discrepancy between giant institutional employers, like Bard School, and their workers. 

Gilbert added that the professor stays nameless within the Legislation College clinic’s criticism to safeguard her security and employment prospects.

“I used to be, and am, terrified,” the professor wrote to the Information. “I’m afraid of the retaliatory actions that Bard School might (and already has) tried to take in opposition to me. However my terror is outweighed by the truth that I additionally have to dwell with myself. I can’t, in good conscience, be a part of the seeming collective tacit settlement at Bard to be silent about unlawful and unethical institutional actions any longer.”

The professor alleged that she found a number of violations of the Clery Act, which requires faculties to report crimes that happen on campus, and that Bard School had been reporting knowledge erroneously. 

Per the Legislation College clinic’s criticism, Bard School’s causes for investigating the professor have been that she engaged college students in subjects of racial subjugation, knowledgeable college students about private experiences of racist assaults within the faculty city and invited a Black artist to campus with out offering proof to Bard that the artist was not “harmful.”

“The USA guarantees to be a welcoming place for every kind of weak folks, however too usually, the non-public pursuits of some highly effective folks perpetuate exclusion,” Spearman-Weaver stated. “This case, like all instances the clinic takes on, represents on a small scale a bigger, nationwide difficulty.”

The Legislation Schol clinic’s authorized compaint describes a number of situations of alleged discrimination as a consequence of Bard School insurance policies. 

The criticism mentions Bard School’s general “racist” and “egregious” conduct. It factors to different Bard professors referring to the plaintiff as “feral” and a “excessive yellow sweetie,” amongst different racially-charged feedback. The criticism additionally cites situational racist remedy during which the plaintiff’s Black visitors have been held at gunpoint by state police in the course of the evening when visiting Bard School.

Spearman-Weaver added that the case is especially related for younger people, including that the case is about “one thing greater” than the professor’s personal experiences.

The professor equally instructed the Information that the lawsuit may be seen via the lens of crucial ethnography, which is a analysis methodology that explores methods to redress social inequities.

“This case is about way more than only one individual,” the professor wrote to the Information. “The scholars who reported assaults and discriminatory actions to me through the years deserve justice, as do the various arduous working previous and current workers of coloration and white Bard workers who’ve tried to do the fitting factor.”

The Yale Legislation College clinic filed the criticism collectively with the California Civil Rights Legislation Group.


Eda Aker covers Yale Legislation College and writes for WKND. She is a sophomore in Timothy Dwight School majoring in World Affairs.

Leave a Reply