Disobedience to court docket orders and anarchy in Nigeria (2)

This prompted one other motion in Abuja filed by Vigeo Energy Restricted earlier than the Honourable Justice Emeka Nwite by which the court docket granted orders restraining the defendants within the go well with from taking up the administration of the BEDC. The court docket order, a duplicate of which I’m privileged to see, additionally directs the administrators appointed by PBE from parading themselves as administrators of the corporate pending the listening to and dedication of the movement on discover. The above orders have been noticed extra within the breach than observance because the Federal Authorities has deployed power by way of the police to take over BEDC and eject the board representatives of Vigeo Energy Restricted, the 60% shareholder of the corporate. The federal government has been carrying on as if the court docket order was a mere piece of bathroom paper. When the police realized that there have been court docket orders and the Inspector-Normal of Police selected to toe the trail of rule of legislation, the defendants within the go well with, who clearly have private pursuits to fulfill, haven’t stopped at any act of self-help to wrest management of the corporate from its reliable house owners. Clearly, from the image depicted by disobedience to court docket orders, the Nigerian authorized system is just not solely embattled however battered. The query then is, how did we get right here? It’s a multifaceted reply. Nigerian courts themselves can’t be absolved of this complication. A lot of the judges administering the legal guidelines are weak, they lack the braveness to implement their very own judgments.

There isn’t a doubt that our judges’ recruitment course of is flawed on this respect. One way or the other, judges with out braveness, integrity, competence, information nonetheless discover themselves on the bench or get appointed. This is applicable equally to our judicial elevation course of. Once they creep in, they compound the commotion on floor. In truth, on fairly a sizeable variety of events, judges are those that proffer excuses for the disobedience of court docket orders. The judges usually neglect the oath they took and the essence of their judgment. This misbehaviour, if it may be so characterised, to say the least, is just not unconnected with the incompetence of a few of them. They perceive not the enforcement mechanism, nor the implication of their judgments being violated. Some are ab initio decapitated by their very own ideas. It isn’t uncommon to listen to judges asking questions in open court docket, will the federal government obey? A few of our judges have even turn into authorities apologists that they even intentionally render imprecise judgments unattainable to execute. Once more, a few of the heads of courts and judges are additionally culpable. A few of the judges are reluctant to signal execution warrants, notably when it issues authorities or authorities associates. This actually is traceable to the subjugation of the welfare of the judges to the whims and caprices of the chief. The judiciary nonetheless depends considerably on the chief for survival. Monetary autonomy for the judiciary continues to be a mirage. Keep in mind that the final agitation for the monetary independence was even compromised and scuttled by a few of the heads of courts. This has decreased the judges to being mere appendages to the chief.   

Moreover, the circumstances and process of enforcements are oftentimes cumbersome and onerous such that they frustrate the victorious occasion. That is fairly other than the astronomical price implication on the occasion searching for to implement. In another situations, you discover judges unwittingly aiding and abetting disobedience by nonetheless entertaining the offensive occasion, as an illustration, granting the occasion discretionary treatment in one other software or in the identical go well with. A rampant one once more is the place the court docket is unwilling to impose prices on the federal government whereas there isn’t a legislation nor rule of courts that forbids identical. All these are incentives to authorities and different disobedient events to undermine judicial authority. The federal government unilaterally additionally frustrates the belief of judgments in opposition to it by way of the usage of counter -force, for which it’s the custodian, or the denial of the usage of the enforcement brokers which it controls.

The police power is deployed by the federal government at will. Culpable additionally in disregard of court docket orders are the Attorneys-Normal, Central Financial institution of Nigeria and different legislation enforcement establishments who frustrate the enforcement mechanism. In the identical vein are legal professionals usually who’ve perfected the acts. Aside from legal professionals utilizing the instrumentality of the legislation to frustrate the belief of judgments, they, at occasions, actively encourage outright disobedience of the court docket orders by their shoppers. What they, nevertheless, neglect within the technique of doing this, is that when the litigants lose confidence within the courts, as already occurring, legal professionals will lose their earnings and don’t have anything to fall upon. 

What then is the answer to this steady flagrant disobedience of court docket orders propelling anarchy in our land? At the beginning, for the reason that breach of the rule of legislation is the crux of disobedience, it would properly be apt to have interaction the political actors, forward of the 2023 elections, on their views and disposition to the rule of legislation, notably on obedience to court docket orders. The excellent news is that the Nigerian Bar Affiliation have taken the initiative in inviting the frontrunners to a session in the course of the Annual Normal Assembly of the Affiliation this month. It solely stays that the dialog be centered across the rule of legislation and respect for the courts.   As hinted above, authorities truly units the stage for the society by way of the management’s disobedience to court docket orders. It’s this mentorship that the followers embrace that has resulted into the confusion the nation is in as we speak. That’s the reason the rising leaders should exhibit management by instance, by way of the understanding and upholding of the rule of legislation, notably obedience to court docket orders. 

The change in narrative should begin with the federal government earlier than the followership embraces the identical. That is one pressing manner of arresting the cankerworm undermining the judiciary.  Following that is the pressing want to alter the disposition of judges to obedience to court docket orders. Judges should notice that the essence of their judicial workplace lies within the obedience to their orders. This then requires strict command of obedience by them.  To this finish, there’s the necessity for pressing overhaul of our judicial recruitment course of.  We’d like brave judges. Courts should even be ready and able to maintain in contempt events, notably authorities officers liable for such disobedience to court docket orders. Going ahead, court docket orders should henceforth be directed in opposition to a specific officer or occupier of an workplace by which the obedience is to be carried out.

The place that is carried out, it then turns into simpler to carry somebody culpable for such disobedience. As well as, we have to simplify the contempt process, notably in level of service. That is the place most contemnors cover. As canvassed earlier, past information of the legislation that’s basically required as a qualification, we’d like judges which are upright in all ramifications and daring. The process for the enforcement of judgments equally must be simplified. As mentioned above, it’s presently cumbersome and complicated, and enough to frustrate the victorious occasion searching for to implement its judgment. The provisions of Part 287 of the Structure that mandate all court docket judgments and choices to be compulsorily enforced by all individuals and authorities should be utilized to quash the availability of Part 84 of the Sheriffs and Civil Course of Act which has made enforcement of judgments in opposition to the federal government to be topic to the discretion of the Lawyer-Normal.

The Structure doesn’t acknowledge such an odious and unconstitutional exception. Related to the foregoing, is the necessity to overview downwards the price implication of imposing a judgment. At present, the price of imposing orders of court docket in Nigeria is prohibitive and discouraging, notably the unofficial and unreceipted sums concerned. There’s a want for an impartial division liable for enforcement whereby you pay the official sum and withdraw whereas the execution takes its course. On this respect, there’s a want for a technology-based course of devoid largely of human interplay which breeds corruption.  Stemming from the expertise of Nigerians, notably because it pertains to enforcement of judgment in opposition to the federal government, there’s a want for the Courts to have its personal armed enforcement brokers impartial of the police or some other govt enforcement company.

In a spot like America, I perceive that there exist armed court docket marshals who execute enforcement. This may require constitutional modification in case the fiat of the President and Commander-in-Chief is inadequate.  Because it pertains to authorities once more, there’s want to start out holding the Attorneys Normal accountable for the misdeeds of their governments because the chief legislation officers at their respective ranges in circumstances of disobedience to court docket orders. This may require subjecting a few of the Attorneys Normal to disciplinary measures by the Authorized Practitioner’s Disciplinary Committee (LPDC). Any Lawyer Normal that doesn’t need such punitive measures, will guarantee compliance with court docket orders or resign from the federal government. 

By the point a few Attorneys Normal resign in a state or on the federal stage, and no lawyer is keen to danger his profession for any Governor, President or govt member, we can be heading someplace. This is perhaps helped additional the place the workplace of the Lawyer Normal is separated from the workplace of Minister or Commissioner for Justice. This is likely one of the methods to tame the ineptitude of execs in authorities.  If all skilled organizations begin holding their members in authorities accountable, some measure of sanity will return to our governance system. Equally, all legal professionals performing equally as authorized advisers in each company and public areas, should be held liable for any disobedience to court docket order.

Adjunct to this are legal professionals usually. As remarked earlier, legal professionals usually and largely additionally promote these acts of disobedience of court docket orders. Erring legal professionals should be subjected to disciplinary measures earlier than the Authorized Practitioners Disciplinary Committee. Attorneys should know that if we don’t urgently overhaul our regulation mechanism, we will quickly be externally regulated and that won’t augur properly for the occupation. Self-introspection is due to this fact crucial now. Lastly, with the hope that the nation will sooner or later have impartial and centered legislators, since disobedience to court docket orders is a breach of the rule of legislation and by extension, the Structure, it routinely turns into an impeachable offence.

Consequently, elected officers of state that disobey court docket orders should face removing process and the place discovered responsible, be faraway from the workplace they occupy. By the point a few of them are made scape goats, sanity will begin returning to the system and by extension, the nation. The court docket by the use of detriment should begin punishing severely disobedience to court docket orders.  To all of us which have shaped the behavior of disobeying court docket orders, both individually or formally, we can’t be heard to be complaining concerning the vices within the nation. We every constantly contribute to the issue as we disobey court docket orders. If we don’t realise this earlier than, I’m certain by now, the truth ought to have dawned on us.

Please allow us to desist from this act. That our nation is just not completely different from a jungle presently is an understatement. To tame the drift, due to this fact, it’s crucial that we admire the nexus between the ugly improvement and pattern of disobedience to court docket orders and the subordination of the rule of legislation. This can be a significant step in direction of our quest to revive legislation and order in our society, a pre-requisite to the expansion of the nation.

Leave a Reply